Severe Asthma ToolkitSevere Asthma Toolkit
HomeAboutSpecific PopulationsRegistriesContributorsContact
Twitter
  • What is Severe Asthma?
    • Overview
    • Definition
    • Prevalence & Burden
    • Pathophysiology
    • Symptoms
    • Severe Asthma Attacks / Exacerbations / Flare-ups
    • Asthma Phenotypes
  • Diagnosis & Assessment
    • Overview
    • Diagnosis Overview
    • Assessment Overview
    • Lung Function Assessments
    • Questionnaires
    • Allergy Assessments
    • Phenotyping
    • Bronchoscopy
    • Imaging
    • Occupational Asthma
  • Management
    • Overview
    • Asthma Education
      • About Severe Asthma
      • Asthma Pathophysiology
      • Medications Education
      • Self-Monitoring
      • Triggers
      • Review
    • Written Action Plans
    • Adherence
    • Inhaler Technique
    • Physical Activity & Exercise
    • Interdisciplinary Approach & Multidimensional Assessment
    • Referral
  • Medications
    • Overview
    • Relievers
    • Preventers / Controllers
    • Add-on Therapies
    • Monoclonal Antibodies
    • Bronchial Thermoplasty
  • Co-Morbidities
    • Overview
    • Pulmonary & Upper Airways
      • Allergic & Non-Allergic Rhinitis
      • Chronic Rhinosinusitis
      • Dysfunctional Breathing
      • Vocal Cord Dysfunction
      • Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease
      • Bronchiectasis
      • Obstructive Sleep Apnoea
    • Extra-Pulmonary
      • Obesity
      • Anxiety & Depression
      • Gastro-oesophageal Reflux Disease (GORD)
      • Osteoporosis
      • Cardiovascular Disease & Metabolic Disease
  • Living with Severe Asthma
    • Overview
    • Daily Symptom Burden
    • Mental & Emotional Health
    • Intimacy & Relationships
    • Self-Management Support
    • Medication Use & Costs
    • Experience of Care
    • Experience of Asthma Attacks
    • Prognosis
  • Establishing a Clinic
    • Overview
    • Set-up
    • Staffing & Multidisciplinary Team Approach
    • Facilities
    • Delivery Approach
    • Tailored Referrals
    • Evaluation
    • Opportunities for Training & Research
    • Barriers & Hurdles
  • Paediatrics
    • Overview
    • Management in Paediatrics
    • Assessment in Paediatrics
    • Alternative Diagnosis & Co-Morbidities in Paediatrics
    • Psychosocial Issues in Paediatrics
    • Medications in Paediatrics
    • Asthma in the Adolescent Population
  • Resources
    • Overview
    • Clinic Recommendations
    • Infographics
    • Asthma Assessment Resources
    • Systematic & Multidimensional Assessment Resources
      • Airway Components
      • Comorbidity Components
      • Risk Factor Components
    • Translation & Implementation
    • Case Studies
    • Presentations
    • Videos
    • Relevant Links
    • Key References

Alternative Diagnosis & Co-Morbidities in Paediatrics

Home Paediatrics & Adolescents Alternative Diagnosis & Co-Morbidities in Paediatrics

It is critical to confirm a diagnosis of asthma and exclude alternative diagnoses. Co-morbidity conditions can also contribute to worsened symptoms and reduced response to therapy.

Unequivocal demonstration of diagnostic criteria for asthma, unequivocal evidence of adherence and effective inhaler technique, and elimination of possible co-morbidities must be documented before assigning the label ‘severe asthma’. Fortunately, true severe asthma in children appears to be very uncommon.

Consider the following approaches to identify either alternative diagnoses or co-morbidities in children with suspected severe asthma.

When Exercise Limitation Is the Dominant Symptom
When Coughing Is a Major Symptom
When Severe Episodic Wheeze Is the Major Symptom
Other Comorbidities Exacerbating Asthma or Alternative Diagnoses
When Exercise Limitation Is the Dominant Symptom

True exercise bronchoconstriction typically occurs after 6 -8 minutes of intense exercise, often with true wheeze and some dry cough.

Consider these alternative diagnoses, if history is not clearly suggestive of asthma (Depiazzi et al. 2016):

  • Reaching physiological limit due to overweight, unfit or very fit but feels performance should be better
  • Reporting of symptoms for the purpose of being excused from sport
  • Dysfunctional breathing is common alone but is also more prevalent in people with asthma. May be treated by interested physiotherapist when identified (Barker et al. 2016). Typically, patients who develop non-sports or trigger-related VCD are ‘protocolled’ in ED due to their dramatic symptoms despite normal oxygen saturation levels. Triggers for VCD and other forms of dysfunctional breathing can be performance (sport, singing etc.) family stress, school stress etc.
  • Vocal cord dysfunction (VCD) where the ‘wheeze’ identified is actually stridor. The inspiratory nature of sound may not be appreciated. Onset is often soon after starting exercise with limited response to salbutamol treatment.
  • Exercised induced laryngomalacia (EILM) often identified in elite athletes working very hard. Symptoms are similar to VCD (responds well to surgery).
  • A variety of rarer alternative diagnoses include cardiac abnormalities and exercise-induced anaphylaxis

For the above conditions, the most valuable investigation is cardiopulmonary exercise testing (if the child is able to able to perform reliable spirometry). Addition of in-exercise laryngoscopy for suspected VCD/EILM may also be useful, if available.

When Coughing Is a Major Symptom
  • Persistent bacterial bronchitis can be either an alternative diagnosis or a co-morbidity (Craven et al. 2013). Typically, includes persistent wet cough most prominent first thing in the morning, when lying in bed and with exercise. May also present as exercise-induced breathlessness due to coughing. Yellowish sputum production containing neutrophils rather than eosinophils, may be detected by microscopy. Consider fibre optic bronchoscopy and lavage if diagnosis is in doubt. Usually responds to an extended course of oral antibiotics (minimum 2 weeks). Broad spectrum antibiotics should be used, unless guided by sputum culture
  • Inhaled foreign body can be determined by history +/- changes in chest X-ray. Will not respond to bronchodilator treatment
  • Tumours are very rarely associated with progressive cough and dyspnoea. Will not respond to bronchodilator treatment
  • Other causes may include cystic fibrosis (CF), primary ciliary dyskinesia (PCD) or bronchiectasis (usually present with wet cough)
When Severe Episodic Wheeze Is the Major Symptom
  • Vocal Cord Dysfunction (VCD) see section above, under exercise limitation
  • Structural extra-thoracic airways problem such as sub-glottis stenosis or vocal cord palsy, resulting in a flattened inspiratory flow loop and stridor
  • A rare cause of steroid-responsive wheeze is large mediastinal lymph nodes due to lymphoma or atypical mycobacterium infection
Other Comorbidities Exacerbating Asthma or Alternative Diagnoses
  • Airways Abnormalities – Tracheobronchomalacia is especially significant. Consider bronchoscopy to diagnose.
  • Allergic Rhinitis – Consider anti-histamine or nasal steroid if complaining of nasal or allergic symptoms.
  • Sleep Deprivation – May be related to poor asthma control, allergic rhinitis symptoms or low mood.
  • Anxiety – See sub-section on Psychosocial Issues in Paediatrics
Previous
Next

Last Updated on February 13, 2019

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Search in posts
Search in pages
Filter by Categories

More results...

  • Overview
  • Management in Paediatrics
  • Assessment in Paediatrics
  • Alternative Diagnosis & Co-Morbidities in Paediatrics
  • Psychosocial Issues in Paediatrics
  • Medications in Paediatrics
  • Asthma in the Adolescent Population
Consider this information in conjunction with the relevant sections:
Diagnosis & Assessment
Management
Medications
Co-Morbidities

We want to know who accesses the Severe Asthma Toolkit and how it is used. Please complete our survey.

Responses will inform the continued development of the Severe Asthma Toolkit and future translation and implementation activities. Any feedback you provide will be greatly appreciated.

Complete Survey

  • Website Terms of Use
  • Website Survey
© Copyright 2018    CRICOS Provider Number 00109J    The University of Newcastle, Australia